Is Meditation Overrated?


Written by Angela Silva

Meditation is an age-old practice with too many supposed benefits to count. It is most frequently associated with stress management, but has also been said to help manage symptoms of depression, asthma, pain and even cancer. The most common form of meditation is called mindful meditation, which is a relaxation practice during which the individual clears the mind and focuses on the present. You won’t have to go far to find very strong supporters of meditation or hear miraculous stories of lives changed from the practice. But does meditation really offer all of these benefits that we hear about?

A team of researchers from Johns Hopkins University wanted to find out. They took a close look at 47 different studies on the effects of meditation to see how strong the results were. They found that only 3 percent of those studies were conducted in a way that could even yield valid results. Overall, they concluded that only moderate evidence exists that mindfulness meditation eases pain, anxiety and depression. They did not have enough data from the studies to make any conclusions about the other claims of mindfulness meditation, such as that it improves mood, or to explore other forms of meditation besides mindfulness meditation.

So what does this tell us about meditation? Is it all a big scam? Millennia of meditation practice suggest there’s something to be gained from it. The results of those studies don’t show that meditation is overrated; they show that it’s underfunded and underinvested. Western medicine is focused on scientifically-proven, cause-and-effect remedies that can stand the test of time. Less attention is given to the mind-body connection and how our own minds and focused efforts can produce actual health benefits. In response to the results of the mentioned study, professor of medicine at Harvard University Allan Goroll said he hopes that research will start focusing on “therapies both conventional and unconventional so we can find out what works.”

When all is said and done, the purported benefits of meditation should not be ignored. Regardless of what current and future scientific research may say, meditation may be a very good option for those who are looking for alternative methods to manage stress, anxiety, depression, pain, sleep, or even chronic diseases. Or if you are just looking for some silence and peace amidst the constant busyness of life, meditation may be just what you need. Scientifically measurable or not, sometimes a peaceful break from our regular life is just the medicine we need to keep going.

“We live, in fact, in a world starved for solitude, silence, and private: and therefore starved for meditation and true friendship.”
-C.S. Lewis

The following two tabs change content below.
Angela Silva

Angela Silva

Writer at Healthy Magazine
Angela graduated from Brigham Young University with a Bachelor of Science in Exercise and Wellness. She also works as a personal fitness trainer and health coach. She enjoys being outdoors, playing the piano, being around animals and spending time with her family.
Angela Silva

Latest posts by Angela Silva (see all)